School Law Newsletter

Form I-9 Reminder

December 2016

As we have previously informed you, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has released a new version of the Form I-9, employment eligibility verification.  This form is dated November 14, 2016, and employers must begin using it no later than January 22, 2017.

A Form I-9 has been required for all new hires after November 6, 1986, to verify employment authorization.  The new version of the Form does not change the substantive questions or the list of acceptable identity and work authorization documents.

The new Form I-9 was designed to be easier to fill out on a computer.  It features interactive form fields, including drop down menus and calendars; embedded instructions; and the automatic generation of the quick response (QR) code when printed.   Although employers can access and complete the new Form I-9 on the USCIS’ website, they must still print a completed Form, obtain hand written signatures, store the hard copy securely, and follow the same reverification practices they have followed when working with the old, paper version of the Form.  Employers can use a plain paper version of the new form which can be printed out from the USCIS website.

Changes in the new version of the Form include the following:

  • Section 1 asks for “other last names used” rather than “other names used;”
  • A dedicated area for including additional information rather than having to add it in the margins;
  • The ability to enter multiple preparers and translators; and
  • A supplemental page for the preparer/translator.

The instructions have also been separated from the Form and include specific instructions for completing each field.

Employers should remain aware, however, that it is still the employer’s responsibility to review proper documentation from the employee and to abide by anti-discrimination provisions.

Considerations For Employers

  1. Decide if you will access and complete the new Form I-9 manually or electronically. Electronic execution will prevent some errors but will require training for those completing the Form.
  1. Determine the identity of and train those in your organization who are responsible for the execution of the new Form I-9 to ensure compliance with the proposed changes.
  1. Consider a Form I-9 compliance review or audit.

Tips For Form I-9 Audits

  • Do not conduct audits that could be seen as discriminatory or retaliatory. If you have many Form I-9s on file it may not be practical to review them all.  You will need to audit a sampling of them.  How you choose that sample is very important.  You should not conduct internal audits based on citizenship status, national origin, or on any other protected classification like gender, age, disability, or religion.  You should also take care not to have it appear that you used a discriminatory basis for sample selection.
  • Employers should not correct errors or omissions in Section One of Form I-9 – have the employee do it. Section One of Form I-9 must be completed by the employee.  Therefore, they must correct any errors or omissions.  Have the employee enter the correct information and initial and date the correction.
  • Employers should correct any errors or omissions in Section 2 or 3 of the Form. Do not conceal the original information via erasure or use of whiteout, and do not backdate any forms. 
  • If you discover an employee never completed a Form I-9 or his/her Form is missing, complete a new Form as soon as possible. Do not backdate the Form.  Employers should attach a signed and dated explanation and state the date employment actually began in the certification portion of Section 2.
  • Do not request specific documents if issues are uncovered with the original documents. The standard for evaluating employment verification documents during an internal audit is the same as when the employee initially completed the Form – does the document reasonably appear to be genuine and relate to individual presenting it?  If you conclude the document does not appear genuine or relate to the individual presenting it, ask the employee for different acceptable documents.  You can tell the employee the problem document will not be accepted again, but you cannot otherwise specify which documents the employee must present.
  • Do not ask existing employees to complete new forms in lieu of conducting an internal audit.
  • Take appropriate action when problems are uncovered. If you receive a credible tip that a specific employee is not work-authorized, you should review the employee’s Form.  Employees who have a deficiency with their Form I-9s should be given a reasonable amount of time to address the deficiencies and should not be summarily discharged.  What is considered “reasonable” should be determined on a case-by-case basis.
  • An internal audit is not complete until you have addressed all issues uncovered. If you document errors and then take no action, that may be worse than not doing the audit itself.

General Tips For Employers

  • Make sure the employee fills out Section 1 on the first day of employment.
  • Make sure the employer fills out Section 2 and 3 within three business days of employment.
  • Keep Form I-9s separate from personnel files. Keeping all of your Form I-9s in one place will make it easier if you ever have a Form I-9 audit from USCIS or the Department of Labor.  It will also make it easier for you to do an internal audit, if desired.
  • Keep photocopies of documents presented by employees. There is a debate as to whether employers should make photocopies of any documents that an employee presents.  Making photocopies is not required.  One argument is if the government audits the employer’s Form I-9s and the government sees documents which are clearly unacceptable that may prove the employer’s guilt.  However, if the employer makes a reasonable effort to ensure the document reasonably appears to be genuine and relates to the individual presenting it, copies of those documents may be the employer’s best defense.  Employers are not expected to spot counterfeits or otherwise be experts on the documents.  They are supposed to use reasonable judgment. 
  • Keep Form I-9s for the later of three years after the employee’s date of hire or one year after the employee’s termination.

Summary

Because the Form I-9 has been around for forty years, employers may become somewhat complacent in completing the Form.  This new Form may help employers comply with their responsibility.  Given the Trump administration will be taking office in January, and given President-elect Trump’s emphasis on immigration control or reform, it would not be surprising to see increased enforcement efforts with respect to Form I-9 compliance in the coming years.  Penalties for non-compliance with Form I-9 requirements can be substantial.  Employers should take time to review their processes and seek guidance if they have questions.  The USCIS website has a lot of useful information as well.  See uscis.gov

 

Michael J. Julka
608.286.7238  |  

James K. Ruhly
608.283.1738  |  

William L. Fahey
608.286.7234  |  

JoAnn M. Hart
608.286.7162  |  

Eileen A. Brownlee
608.822.3251  |  

Doug Witte
608.283.7529  |  

Steve Zach
608.283.1736  |  

Frank C. Sutherland
608.286.7243  |  

Richard F. Verstegen
608.286.7233  |  

David P. Weller
608.286.7235  |  

Jennifer S. Mirus
608.283.1799  |  

Rhonda R. Hazen
608.283.1724  |  

M. Tess O’Brien-Heinzen
608.283.1798  |  

Andy DeClercq
608.283.1734  |  

Brian P. Goodman
608.283.1722  |  

DISCLAIMER: Boardman & Clark LLP provides this material as information about legal issues and not to give legal advice. In addition, this material may quickly become outdated. Anyone referencing this material must update the information presented to ensure accuracy. The use of the materials does not establish an attorney-client relationship, and Boardman & Clark LLP recommends the use of legal counsel on specific matters.